Men Of Reddit Were Asked What They Want For Christmas. Almost Nobody Asked For A Thing.

Somebody posted a thread Wednesday morning asking a simple question.

Men of Reddit: what do you actually want for Christmas?

Thousands of answers came in. The pattern was immediate and almost unanimous.

Peace and quiet. Time with family. A few practical items somebody would otherwise have to buy for himself.

That was it. That was the list.

What did not show up.

No watches. No electronics. No golf clubs, no grills, no gadget that was invented in March and will be in a drawer by February.

The traditional American Christmas gift for men, which is to say an object selected under duress by a spouse who has run out of time, barely appeared in the thread at all.

And the "practical items" answers are their own small comedy.

Socks. Good ones.

A nice belt, because the current one has a crack in it that has been getting worse since spring.

New work gloves. A decent flashlight. The specific screwdriver set, not the assortment from the hardware aisle.

A man will carry a wallet that has been disintegrating for four years and will not replace it, because replacing it requires making a decision about a wallet, and there is always something else that needs doing.

So he puts it on a Christmas list and waits.

Now the part that is not funny.

The most common answer in that thread was not a product.

Peace and quiet. Time with family. An afternoon where nobody needs anything.

Thousands of grown men were asked what they want and a large share of them said a day off and some conversation.

That is worth sitting with for a second rather than laughing past.

It suggests that a lot of men in this country are stretched further than they let on, and that the thing they actually want is not purchasable, which is why they have stopped asking for it and started asking for socks instead.

The gift-giving problem this creates.

Here is the practical bind every wife and mother reading this already knows.

You cannot wrap peace and quiet. It does not photograph well under a tree, children cannot hand it to him, and nobody has ever opened a box containing an afternoon.

So the whole economy of men's Christmas gifts exists to solve a problem that is not actually about gifts, and the result is a national surplus of cologne nobody wears and tools nobody needed.

But the thread does point at an answer, and it is cheaper than anything in a catalog.

What the thread actually suggests you do.

Give him the Saturday.

Not a voucher. Not a joke coupon book from 1998. An actual day where somebody else handles the house, the kids, the errands and the phone, and he is permitted to do nothing or to finally fix the thing in the garage he has been circling since August.

Then buy the socks. Buy the belt. Buy the specific screwdriver set, because he will never buy it himself and he will use it for twenty years and think about you every time.

Those two things together cost less than one bad gadget and they are the entire list.

One more observation.

There is a version of this thread that gets written up as men being simple, or low maintenance, or easy to shop for.

That is not what is in it.

What is in it is several thousand men saying, in various ways, that the best thing anyone could give them is a little room to breathe and some time with the people they are working that hard for.

That is not simple. That is just quiet about it.

Merry Christmas. Get him the gloves.

READ THIS NEXT

GET UPDATES

© 2026 news.basedapparel.com, Privacy Policy